Socialism and Zionism: two different Jewish perspectives
By Morten Ting
Jewish Socialism has its roots in Russia while the Zionist movement developed in Western Europe. They both offered European Jewry a future but were vastly different in their outlook.
The Jewish Social Democrats, algemeyner judisher arbeterforbund fun poyln, lite un rusland or Bund, envisaged a Jewish future hand in hand with other nations in a multicultural society based on the Soviet model. Theodor Herzl had visions of a Jewish state based on the French or German model.
The Bundists wanted to create a Socialist society free of class differentiation. Herzl argued for Jewish Capitalism.
The Bundist wanted to created something "here", in Europe, while the zionists wanted to created something "there", in Palestine.
The Bundists represented the Yiddish-speaking Ashkenazi Jews, while the Zionists spoke on behalf of all the world's Jews.